Karl Lagerfeld says, “Fashion is a language that creates itself in clothes to interpret reality.” Indeed, for centuries, fashion has been one of the most powerful forms of expression through which people define themselves. In Ancient Egypt, linen garments, jewellery and headdresses indicated social status, while in Greek and Roman civilizations, the quality, colour and manner of use of fabric conveyed meanings about citizenship and status. Thus, throughout the ages, fashion has been not merely an element that covers the body, but a visible memory reflecting the political, social and economic transformations of its time.
A fashion piece passes through countless stages before reaching the runway from the atelier. Fabric, cut, pattern and craftsmanship come together to create the piece’s distinctive narrative. However, in order to speak of the language of fashion, it is also necessary to discuss how this creative journey is protected. Because details create fashion, and when it comes to design, sometimes even a single stitch can determine the originality of a work.
Chanel, under the creative direction of Karl Lagerfeld, one of the most influential designers in recent fashion history, also confronted this reality. The World Tricot–Chanel case is one of the striking examples demonstrating why even the question of who owns a single stitch matters. The French knitwear atelier World Tricot claimed that an original embroidery sample it had presented to Chanel was initially rejected, but was later used in a highly similar form in a Chanel collection under Lagerfeld’s direction. In the dispute brought before the courts in 2005, the Paris Court of Appeal recognised the embroidery in question as an original collective work belonging to World Tricot within the meaning of French law and ruled that Chanel had infringed copyright. Thus, what became visible on the runway was not merely a design, but also one of fashion’s most fundamental legal questions: Is a design created by the name of the fashion house, or by the hands that bring it into being?
Law, of course, did not knock on fashion’s door during the Karl Lagerfeld era. Let us now travel a little further back in time and, as the calendar shows the year 1911, take a look at the legal struggle of French couturier Paul Poiret, who travelled to New York. When Poiret saw counterfeit labels bearing his name attached to low-quality products, he was confronted with the reality that not only a designer’s lines, but also his name and reputation could be imitated. While Poiret pursued legal action against the person producing the label, he also called upon French couturiers to act together to protect their creativity. Because for him, a name attached to a dress was not merely an ordinary label sewn onto fabric; it was a signature carrying the designer’s labour, aesthetic world and reputation.
By 1929, the decision in Cheney Brothers v. Doris Silk Corporation emerged as one of the early and foundational precedents of modern fashion law and left us with a difficult question to answer: Is creativity sufficient to prevent imitation in the absence of legal protection? Cheney Brothers created numerous original silk fabric patterns each season, but due to the rapidly changing nature of fashion, it was unable to obtain protection for all of them. Doris Silk Corporation, meanwhile, copied one of the patterns that had attracted attention in the market and offered it for sale at a lower price. When the dispute came before the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in 1929, the court, despite assuming that the design had been copied, refused to create special protection in favour of Cheney Brothers. According to Judge Learned Hand’s approach, an exclusive right could not be established over a design that the law did not expressly protect merely on the basis of labour and creativity.
As can be seen, fashion law is not an independent and closed field whose boundaries can be drawn by a single statute; rather, it is a multilayered structure that brings together different legal disciplines within the same stitch throughout fashion’s journey from production to the runway and from there to the consumer. Paul Poiret’s struggle against counterfeit labels bearing his name brought trademark rights, unfair competition and the protection of commercial reputation to the fore; the decision in Cheney Brothers v. Doris Silk Corporation highlighted the protection gap between design, patent and copyright law; while the World Tricot–Chanel case raised issues of authorship, originality, contractual relationships and the creative labour of independent ateliers. Therefore, understanding fashion law requires looking not only at the form of a dress, but also at the label on it, the hands that created its pattern, the atelier in which it was produced, the contract between the parties and the conditions under which it was placed on the market. Because just as fashion is not created from a single fabric, the law that protects it is not woven from a single branch of law. Moreover, this weave continues to expand from labour and human rights law to consumer and advertising law, from competition law to customs regulations, and from electronic commerce to sustainability regulations.
In this series, which we will create around the axis of fashion law, we will explore the creative journey extending from the transformation of an idea born in the designer’s mind into a tangible and original design to its presentation on the runway and its becoming part of a collection. As we witness the journeys of brands, we will also accompany the struggles of designers, artists and producers to protect their labour. Because in fashion, no detail is accidental; and in law, what is worthy of protection is often hidden precisely in that detail.
Selin Ceren Canbulut Dursun, Associate
REFERENCES:
- https://www.vogue.co.uk/article/chanel-world-tricot-court-legal-battle-for-counterfeiting
- https://www.vogue.co.uk/article/paul-poiret?utm
- https://cyber.harvard.edu/metaschool/fisher/linking/doctrine/cheney.html













